I have been reading 'Psychopathic Cultures and Toxic Empires' by Will Black this week, and I would thoroughly recommend it. Mr Black discusses psychopathy in general, outlining the characteristics often found in such people, such as selfishness, greed, impulsivity, risk-taking and lack of empathy. He then goes on to note that some professions such as banking, politics and the law tend to attract more psychopaths than might be expected, and how such people will tend to 'infect' such cultures with psychopathic characteristics which may persist long after those who introduced that culture have moved on. This is not to say that all bankers or politicians or lawyers are psychopaths, but that the tendency of most people to the herd norm will tend to perpetuate such cultures once established.
The book makes a convincing case for such cultures being present in our current society, with the cult of austerity, for example, being shown to be a toxic construct based on greed and selfishness. Mr Black also references recent child sexual abuse scandals involving people such as Jimmy Savile and demonstrates how such people influence the culture round about them to lead ordinary people to look the other way when faced with abuse taking place in plain sight.
This thesis also explains something about the differences in culture between Scotland and England in terms of the independence debate. It's often been observed that, when surveyed on matters political, respondents in Scotland and England are more alike than different. This then leads to claims that, as the two countries are very similar, it cannot be argued that they are sufficiently different to justify independence for Scotland. However, this feeling that the cultures are different can be explained by the observation that psychopathic tendencies in a culture can be stopped by societies observing that psychopathic behaviour violates group norms and therefore encouraging the humane norms and discouraging the undesirable behaviours. Scotland is a very much smaller country in terms of population than England and has a 'kent his faither' attitude which is used to counter tendencies to arrogance and feelings of superiority. This can, of course, be limiting, but is also a useful way of providing a 'norm' against which behaviour can be measured.
Mr Black argues his case well and adds a new dimension to our understanding of our current society, and because we have a better understanding we can begin to try and move away from 'infected' cultures to something far more humane.
Monday, 6 July 2015
Wednesday, 1 July 2015
Power to the people
It's been said for some time now that the internet is the great equaliser. Everyone has equal access to it and no-one knows you're a dog, as the old saying goes. For that matter, no-one knows you're a celebrity, a politician or a convicted murderer. Anyone can have a blog, a Twitter account or a website and make their voice heard.
The old media hate the internet. They were used to having control over the dissemination of information - what to tell, what not to tell, how to express information to influence opinion. Now they can craft their articles with whatever slant they like, only to find it deconstructed by the denizens of the internet. Sites like Wikileaks mean that information that governments don't want the general public to see can be made available. Contrary opinions to those peddled by the mainstream media are freely available to people.
This is not to say that the internet isn't full of bad information, trolling and sometimes repugnant content. Nevertheless, there is still a great deal of information out there at everyone's disposal.
Recently, however, things have moved up a notch, courtesy of a very simple idea called crowdfunding. It has been used to raise money for a court action against Alastair Carmichael following his admission that he lied about his knowledge of the 'Frenchgate' memo. And today we have another one to try and raise the 1.6bn Euros needed to make Greece's next debt payment. That last one may seem ridiculous, but at the time of writing it has raised just under 1 million Euros. Yes, you read that right, 1 million Euros.
Suddenly, courtesy of crowdfunding, justice is no longer the exclusive domain of the rich. Solving financial problems is no longer restricted to politicians and their posturing. Ordinary people can subvert the existing political systems. Suppose the Greek bailout crowdfunder succeeds (unlikely I know but bear with me). Where does that leave politicians? All their posturing and backroom deals are for naught if the ordinary people can simply bypass them and solve the problem collectively.
I sense a shift in the zeitgeist from individualism to collectivism. Won't that put the cat amongst the pigeons.
The old media hate the internet. They were used to having control over the dissemination of information - what to tell, what not to tell, how to express information to influence opinion. Now they can craft their articles with whatever slant they like, only to find it deconstructed by the denizens of the internet. Sites like Wikileaks mean that information that governments don't want the general public to see can be made available. Contrary opinions to those peddled by the mainstream media are freely available to people.
This is not to say that the internet isn't full of bad information, trolling and sometimes repugnant content. Nevertheless, there is still a great deal of information out there at everyone's disposal.
Recently, however, things have moved up a notch, courtesy of a very simple idea called crowdfunding. It has been used to raise money for a court action against Alastair Carmichael following his admission that he lied about his knowledge of the 'Frenchgate' memo. And today we have another one to try and raise the 1.6bn Euros needed to make Greece's next debt payment. That last one may seem ridiculous, but at the time of writing it has raised just under 1 million Euros. Yes, you read that right, 1 million Euros.
Suddenly, courtesy of crowdfunding, justice is no longer the exclusive domain of the rich. Solving financial problems is no longer restricted to politicians and their posturing. Ordinary people can subvert the existing political systems. Suppose the Greek bailout crowdfunder succeeds (unlikely I know but bear with me). Where does that leave politicians? All their posturing and backroom deals are for naught if the ordinary people can simply bypass them and solve the problem collectively.
I sense a shift in the zeitgeist from individualism to collectivism. Won't that put the cat amongst the pigeons.
Monday, 29 June 2015
Lightning rod
In yesterday's Observer there was an interview with Angus Robertson, SNP leader in the House of Commons, in which he explained how Scotland could well instigate another referendum on independence if David Cameron fails to deliver on further devolution for Scotland. It was a piece that didn't say anything startling or that hadn't been said before. Positively unremarkable, in fact. What was remarkable was the amount of bile, venom and nastiness towards the SNP and the Scots in the comments.
We're getting kind of used to this by now. We're getting used to the conflation of the SNP with Scotland and the Scots. We're getting used to the constant denigration, contempt and, in some cases, downright hatred being expressed towards us, all for the heinous crime of suggesting we might want to run our own country. Most of it is based on proving we are 'too wee, too poor, too stupid' to even think about running a country, so we should just get back in our box.
This started during indyref, but has increased recently, especially after the Tories' General Election campaign, which portrayed the SNP/Scots as the bogeyman, the imminent threat to the British way of life. It is not discouraged by the government. Take, for example, the recent bogus story on Scotland no longer paying for the Queen to the tune of £2 million quid. This was swiftly debunked by Nicola Sturgeon and the Treasury, but Jacob Rees-Mogg was moved to suggest in the House of Commons that SNP MPs should be forced to reaffirm their loyalty to the Queen and the British state as a result of it.
Of course, the story about the evil Nationalists leaving the Queen short of £2 million conveniently drew attention away from the fact that she is in fact getting an increase of £3 million in her allowance this year. And this is, I think, the whole point. We in Scotland have been 'othered' and we are now a convenient lightning rod for the Government, something that they can use to deflect attention from the worst of their policies. Got to implement something unpopular? Plant a nice story about the nasty SNP/Scots in the mainstream media and get it done while people express their rage against them.
The problem is that this approach simply brings Scottish independence closer. Sooner or later most Scots will become fed up with being scapegoats. Indyref2 will happen, and when it does it is far less likely that the Unionist side will win. The Government, however, pleased to have an easy distraction from opposition to their policies, will carry on in the same vein, employing their usual short-termist thinking.
So, lightning rod we are for the moment. But lightning rods imply the presence of storms, and storms can be powerful things that cannot be controlled, something that Westminster might like to bear in mind. The energy of the storm has to go somewhere, and lightning rods concentrate and direct that energy.
We're getting kind of used to this by now. We're getting used to the conflation of the SNP with Scotland and the Scots. We're getting used to the constant denigration, contempt and, in some cases, downright hatred being expressed towards us, all for the heinous crime of suggesting we might want to run our own country. Most of it is based on proving we are 'too wee, too poor, too stupid' to even think about running a country, so we should just get back in our box.
This started during indyref, but has increased recently, especially after the Tories' General Election campaign, which portrayed the SNP/Scots as the bogeyman, the imminent threat to the British way of life. It is not discouraged by the government. Take, for example, the recent bogus story on Scotland no longer paying for the Queen to the tune of £2 million quid. This was swiftly debunked by Nicola Sturgeon and the Treasury, but Jacob Rees-Mogg was moved to suggest in the House of Commons that SNP MPs should be forced to reaffirm their loyalty to the Queen and the British state as a result of it.
Of course, the story about the evil Nationalists leaving the Queen short of £2 million conveniently drew attention away from the fact that she is in fact getting an increase of £3 million in her allowance this year. And this is, I think, the whole point. We in Scotland have been 'othered' and we are now a convenient lightning rod for the Government, something that they can use to deflect attention from the worst of their policies. Got to implement something unpopular? Plant a nice story about the nasty SNP/Scots in the mainstream media and get it done while people express their rage against them.
The problem is that this approach simply brings Scottish independence closer. Sooner or later most Scots will become fed up with being scapegoats. Indyref2 will happen, and when it does it is far less likely that the Unionist side will win. The Government, however, pleased to have an easy distraction from opposition to their policies, will carry on in the same vein, employing their usual short-termist thinking.
So, lightning rod we are for the moment. But lightning rods imply the presence of storms, and storms can be powerful things that cannot be controlled, something that Westminster might like to bear in mind. The energy of the storm has to go somewhere, and lightning rods concentrate and direct that energy.
Saturday, 27 June 2015
Caught by the listicles
Cybernats everywhere are trembling in their boots this morning. The Scottish Labour thought police have compiled a 51-page dossier of people who have used the words 'quisling' or 'traitor' or who have used swear words about Scottish Labour party members on Twitter. Trembling with anticipation to see if they have been included on the list. And, given the dossier lists only 46 people out of the 115,000 SNP members, it's kind of like winning the lottery. I can almost hear the squeals of excitement amid the much larger sighs of disappointment as people peruse the leaked dossier to see if they're on it.
The dossier itself is a bit of an anti-climax. On reading the tweets you are left with a feeling of 'is that it?'. And one has to ask what Scottish Labour hope to achieve by this. Currently leaderless and without a coherent plan, this is what they choose to spend their time and resources on?
Of course, Scottish Labour internally would never use such language. Everything in the land of Scottish Labour is all kittens and puppies, rainbows and unicorns. No-one ever disagrees with anyone else, and there are no divisions, or in-fighting. and no-one on the Unionist side has ever done a similar thing with the SNP as their target.
And what has the reaction on Twitter? As usual, humour. The hashtag #ClypeGate is being used to discuss the list, and how appropriate that is. The list very much has the feel of a schoolchild shouting 'Miss, miss, so-and-so used a bad word!' There is also a #CybernatAMovieQuote.
The real test of this will be the reaction of the SNP leadership. Handling this by a draconian crackdown might well see them start to lose members as well has giving the appearance of dancing to Scottish Labour's tune.
The real lesson of this whole affair is that it would appear that, in Scottish Labour's view, free speech is fine, but only if it's not directed at them. No-one is to be allowed to have an opinion unless it is an approved opinion. I do believe the world has seem something like this before. Mr McCarthy would be proud.
The dossier itself is a bit of an anti-climax. On reading the tweets you are left with a feeling of 'is that it?'. And one has to ask what Scottish Labour hope to achieve by this. Currently leaderless and without a coherent plan, this is what they choose to spend their time and resources on?
Of course, Scottish Labour internally would never use such language. Everything in the land of Scottish Labour is all kittens and puppies, rainbows and unicorns. No-one ever disagrees with anyone else, and there are no divisions, or in-fighting. and no-one on the Unionist side has ever done a similar thing with the SNP as their target.
And what has the reaction on Twitter? As usual, humour. The hashtag #ClypeGate is being used to discuss the list, and how appropriate that is. The list very much has the feel of a schoolchild shouting 'Miss, miss, so-and-so used a bad word!' There is also a #CybernatAMovieQuote.
The real test of this will be the reaction of the SNP leadership. Handling this by a draconian crackdown might well see them start to lose members as well has giving the appearance of dancing to Scottish Labour's tune.
The real lesson of this whole affair is that it would appear that, in Scottish Labour's view, free speech is fine, but only if it's not directed at them. No-one is to be allowed to have an opinion unless it is an approved opinion. I do believe the world has seem something like this before. Mr McCarthy would be proud.
Friday, 26 June 2015
Drip, drip, drip
Following on from my previous blog on this subject, we have an interesting little postscript to the thoroughly debunked story of Scotland withholding money from the Queen once the Scottish Government has control of the Crown Estates there. Tory MP Jacob Rees-Mogg has called for all SNP MPs to be made to reaffirm their loyalty to the Crown. He made the request to Chris Grayling, the Leader of the Commons, and he said
The problem with the constant dripping of negative stories about the Scots is that it is not going unnoticed up here, and eventually the people of Scotland will have had enough. Keep this up and the next referendum will be lost by the Unionists. So why are they doing it?
Partly it's about fear, as I mentioned previously. It's the equivalent of expressing contempt for something which has recently terrified you in an attempt to show you're not afraid. No-one is fooled by this. I can't help wondering, though, if it's a deliberate provocation of the more intemperate elements of the independence supporters. Keep it up, and there are some who might well be tempted to take retaliatory action. And if that happens, military occupation would be considered justifiable by Westminster, on the basis that they are protecting the UK from terrorism.
Seem unlikely? A bit conspiracy theory gone mad? Maybe, but it's not beyond the realms of possibility. That's why we must wait until the time is right for another referendum and ignore the constant drip, drip, drip of poison. And this time, we will win.
Following the brouhaha there has been over the Crown Estate, the Scotland Bill and the Sovereign Grant Act, will you make time available for a debate to allow our friends in the Scottish National Party to reaffirm their loyalty to our and their sovereign?This is just yet another instance of the 'othering' of Scotland that was a large part of the General Election campaign, and shows an increasing portrayal of the Scots as untrustworthy and ungrateful. They really haven't forgiven us for coming so close to winning the referendum, have they?
The problem with the constant dripping of negative stories about the Scots is that it is not going unnoticed up here, and eventually the people of Scotland will have had enough. Keep this up and the next referendum will be lost by the Unionists. So why are they doing it?
Partly it's about fear, as I mentioned previously. It's the equivalent of expressing contempt for something which has recently terrified you in an attempt to show you're not afraid. No-one is fooled by this. I can't help wondering, though, if it's a deliberate provocation of the more intemperate elements of the independence supporters. Keep it up, and there are some who might well be tempted to take retaliatory action. And if that happens, military occupation would be considered justifiable by Westminster, on the basis that they are protecting the UK from terrorism.
Seem unlikely? A bit conspiracy theory gone mad? Maybe, but it's not beyond the realms of possibility. That's why we must wait until the time is right for another referendum and ignore the constant drip, drip, drip of poison. And this time, we will win.
Sticks and stones
This week we have had an extensive piece by Margaret Curran in the Daily Mail on the abuse she has suffered on Twitter, together with a screaming exposé of how some of Nicola Sturgeon's followers are 'vile cybernats'.
Let's get one thing clear. I don't condone personal attacks on people. Making nasty comments on someone's appearance is an unpleasant thing to do and completely unnecessary. It's behaviour that should have been left behind at the primary school stage, and really speaks more to the immaturity of the insulter than anything else. Similarly calling people 'cunts' is not the way to have a reasoned debate or persuade them of the merits of your point of view.
Having said all that, however, as a politician you can't afford to be thin-skinned. You have to accept that some people are not going to like your party's policies and are not going to have the verbal tools to debate them with you, so will resort to what they think will hurt you.
It's always Twitter that is singled out as being a venomous bear-pit, and it's worth thinking about why that is. For the first time the internet has given ordinary people the ability to interact with politicians on a real-time basis. However, it does this at a remove, so people feel they can say whatever comes into their heads without consequences. After all, the person isn't standing in front of you, so you can't see the hurt you may be causing, and there's no immediate danger of physical retaliation.
Politicians have got used to being in the Westminster bubble, where the staff are deferential and their opponents by and large respectful. It must therefore come as a bit of a shock to be exposed to the electorate in the raw, as it were. Mind you, for any politician who has taken the time to meet their constituents, the language used, the language of the streets, while distasteful, should not be a surprise. On the streets you don't have formal debates and handshakes afterwards.
Another aspect to this is that the people acting this way on Twitter are pretty much all men. In my experience men debate differently from women. They will insult each other, and to the outsider it can sound like fighting talk. Insults will be traded, all with the aim of winning. Afterwards, however, the participants will be best of friends. Women, by contrast, will generally try and come to a consensus, and can find the male debating style intimidating.
In my youth my mother used to tell me 'sticks and stones may break my bones but names will never hurt me'. She also taught me that the best way to deal with insults was to ignore them. It was sound advice, and I'm quite sure that Ms Curran was given similar advice while growing up. So why doesn't she follow it? Because any opportunity for 'SNP Baaaad!' must be seized and given maximum exposure. After all, what other political party is held to account for the actions of their supporters on the internet? It's not as if supporters of Scottish independence (note: they're not all SNP members) are the only ones who are nasty on Twitter, but you don't hear the Labour party being held to account for the behaviour of their supporters on the same medium. Hypocrisy much?
Let's get one thing clear. I don't condone personal attacks on people. Making nasty comments on someone's appearance is an unpleasant thing to do and completely unnecessary. It's behaviour that should have been left behind at the primary school stage, and really speaks more to the immaturity of the insulter than anything else. Similarly calling people 'cunts' is not the way to have a reasoned debate or persuade them of the merits of your point of view.
Having said all that, however, as a politician you can't afford to be thin-skinned. You have to accept that some people are not going to like your party's policies and are not going to have the verbal tools to debate them with you, so will resort to what they think will hurt you.
It's always Twitter that is singled out as being a venomous bear-pit, and it's worth thinking about why that is. For the first time the internet has given ordinary people the ability to interact with politicians on a real-time basis. However, it does this at a remove, so people feel they can say whatever comes into their heads without consequences. After all, the person isn't standing in front of you, so you can't see the hurt you may be causing, and there's no immediate danger of physical retaliation.
Politicians have got used to being in the Westminster bubble, where the staff are deferential and their opponents by and large respectful. It must therefore come as a bit of a shock to be exposed to the electorate in the raw, as it were. Mind you, for any politician who has taken the time to meet their constituents, the language used, the language of the streets, while distasteful, should not be a surprise. On the streets you don't have formal debates and handshakes afterwards.
Another aspect to this is that the people acting this way on Twitter are pretty much all men. In my experience men debate differently from women. They will insult each other, and to the outsider it can sound like fighting talk. Insults will be traded, all with the aim of winning. Afterwards, however, the participants will be best of friends. Women, by contrast, will generally try and come to a consensus, and can find the male debating style intimidating.
In my youth my mother used to tell me 'sticks and stones may break my bones but names will never hurt me'. She also taught me that the best way to deal with insults was to ignore them. It was sound advice, and I'm quite sure that Ms Curran was given similar advice while growing up. So why doesn't she follow it? Because any opportunity for 'SNP Baaaad!' must be seized and given maximum exposure. After all, what other political party is held to account for the actions of their supporters on the internet? It's not as if supporters of Scottish independence (note: they're not all SNP members) are the only ones who are nasty on Twitter, but you don't hear the Labour party being held to account for the behaviour of their supporters on the same medium. Hypocrisy much?
Thursday, 25 June 2015
Whistling past the graveyard
Not content with having attempted to smear the reputation of Nicola Sturgeon with the Frenchgate shenanigans, the Daily Telegraph decided to have another go. This time we have a report about how Scotland will be depriving the Queen of a cool £2 billion if and when the Scottish Government takes over management of the Crown Estates. Showing clearly that they have learned no lessons from Frenchgate, the paper did not bother to check the facts, or it would have discovered that, as the Queen's stipend is a reserved matter and is paid from general taxation, the Scottish government don't have the power to do this even if they wanted to. Inevitably the whole thing was debunked by the Scottish government and (perhaps surprisingly) by the Treasury in short order, and the palace official who started the whole thing was forced to apologise.
Last week we also had the debate on the Scotland Bill, the legislation that is supposed to implement the recommendations of the Smith Commission, and what a shambles that has turned into. The very first sentence of the Smith Commission report states that the Scottish Parliament should be made permanent, but an amendment by the SNP which would have required the Scottish people to agree to its abolition via a referendum was voted down by the Tories, so loath are they to give up any control. Anything deemed 'problematic or controversial' in the Smith Commission report has also been omitted from the Scotland Bill. We have gone from the fevered promises of the Vow to the watered-down Smith Commission to the positively homeopathic Scotland Bill.
What do these things tell us? They tell me that the Establishment is very afraid of the Scots. Sure, they won the referendum, but not by nearly as much of a margin as they had anticipated. Indeed the Vow itself was the result of a panic in the higher echelons when polls started to show the Yes side in the lead. Since then we have heard nothing but derision of the SNP and by extension of Scotland and its people. There is a daily diet of 'SNP accused...' and 'Scottish government forced to deny...'.
It has to be assumed that this constant derision has one aim - to try and put Scotland and the Scots back in their box. They've reckoned without the thrawn streak in the Scottish character though. The streak that will make us say 'Is that right?' and 'Oh can't we?' Meantime it's all just whistling past the graveyard on the part of the Establishment.
Last week we also had the debate on the Scotland Bill, the legislation that is supposed to implement the recommendations of the Smith Commission, and what a shambles that has turned into. The very first sentence of the Smith Commission report states that the Scottish Parliament should be made permanent, but an amendment by the SNP which would have required the Scottish people to agree to its abolition via a referendum was voted down by the Tories, so loath are they to give up any control. Anything deemed 'problematic or controversial' in the Smith Commission report has also been omitted from the Scotland Bill. We have gone from the fevered promises of the Vow to the watered-down Smith Commission to the positively homeopathic Scotland Bill.
What do these things tell us? They tell me that the Establishment is very afraid of the Scots. Sure, they won the referendum, but not by nearly as much of a margin as they had anticipated. Indeed the Vow itself was the result of a panic in the higher echelons when polls started to show the Yes side in the lead. Since then we have heard nothing but derision of the SNP and by extension of Scotland and its people. There is a daily diet of 'SNP accused...' and 'Scottish government forced to deny...'.
It has to be assumed that this constant derision has one aim - to try and put Scotland and the Scots back in their box. They've reckoned without the thrawn streak in the Scottish character though. The streak that will make us say 'Is that right?' and 'Oh can't we?' Meantime it's all just whistling past the graveyard on the part of the Establishment.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)