Pages

Thursday, 20 November 2014

A piece of history

With her election as Scotland's First Minister yesterday, Nicola Sturgeon made a little bit of Scottish history by being the first woman to hold the post.  It's a job she has worked towards all her life, and I look forward to seeing what she will do.

She had a rival candidate in Ruth Davidson, who stood as a Unionist candidate against her.  The votes were cast as follows:
Nicola Sturgeon 66
Ruth Davidson 15
Abstentions 39

The current make-up of the Scottish Parliament is as follows:
SNP 64
Labour 38
Conservatives 15
Liberal Democrats 5
Scottish Greens 2
Independent 3
No party affiliation 1

I would guess that the SNP and Scottish Greens voted for Nicola Sturgeon, while the Conservatives voted for Ruth Davidson, meaning that the Labour MSPs pretty much abstained en masse.  My, those groups are sour.

Speaking of which, Kezia Dugdale wrote a column in the Daily Record filled with bile and spite, entitled 'Queen Nicola Sturgeon must put people before her party'.  Now I could be wrong, but do I detect a slight hint of jealousy here?  There are comparisons to Margaret Thatcher and demands for Ms Sturgeon to implement policies that the Parliament she leads does not have the power to do.  Ms Dugdale is apparently one of the bright young things in the Labour party in Scotland, in which case I can only pity them for the lack of talent in their ranks if this is the best they've got to offer.

Ms Sturgeon herself hopes that her success will inspire other girls and young women by example, showing them that anything is possible if you have the talent and determination to make it happen.  Time will tell on that score, but it's certainly a positive thing for them to see.

We saw during the referendum that Ms Sturgeon is no shrinking violet and will not be a pushover for her opponents.  This can only be good for Scotland generally, whether in seeking more powers for Holyrood or, when the time is right, independence.

Wednesday, 19 November 2014

Coming to a manifesto near you

Survation have just released the results of a survey on behalf of Progressive Polling which asked 1002 SNP voters what policies would be more likely to make them vote Labour.  The respondents were people resident in Scotland aged 16 or over who had declared an intention within the last year to vote for SNP at the next General Election or Scottish General Election.  The headline results were
  • A policy of a mandatory living wage would make 37% more likely to vote Labour

  • A commitment to permanently abolishing tuition fees for university education in Scotland would make 30% more likely to vote Labour

  • Promising to decommission the Trident nuclear weapons system would make 30% more likely to vote Labour

  • A policy to re-nationalise Scottish rail services would make 27% more likely to vote Labour

  • Promising free nursery places for children from the age of 12 months would make 21% more likely to vote Labour

Let's take a look at these policies.

Decommissioning of Trident
A bone of contention within the Labour party in Scotland.  Neil Findlay this week talked of his intention to get rid of Trident, which was fine until it was pointed that Ed Milliband is in favour of retaining it and would therefore overrule this.  Jim Murphy is known to be in favour of retaining it, while Sarah Boyack is supports a similar position to Neil Findlay.
Verdict: highly unlikely to be on the Labour manifesto.

Mandatory living wage
The Scottish government are currently paying all staff working directly for them the living wage.  However, a proposal by Labour to ensure that paying the living wage be made a condition of all public sector contracts was defeated, citing concerns that this would breach EU law and leave public bodies open to legal action.  The Scottish government did agree that companies bidding for public sector contracts should be assessed on their willingness to pay a living wage.
Verdict: A possible area of weakness for the SNP, so a good candidate to be on the Labour manifesto

Permanent abolition of tuition fees
Scottish students currently pay no tuition fees, and Nicola Sturgeon has declared that she will never support bringing them in.  Labour's policy in Scotland was, until recently, that free tuition was not economically viable and tended to favour the economically privileged.  However, Kezia Dugdale is apparently hopeful that Labour can change their 'direction of travel' on this one, providing that there is 'sufficient funding was also available to widen access and to reduce the student drop-out rate in the country'.
Verdict: A possibility for the Labour manifesto, depending on the outcome of the leadership election

Re-nationalise the Scottish rail services
This surfaced over the recent award of the franchise held by ScotRail to the Dutch company Abellio.  To be fair to the Scottish government, they don't have a choice on this, as the 1993 Railways Act specifically rules out awarding the franchise to any company directly owned by the UK taxpayer.  This would therefore require the Labour party to promise to amend the law at UK level to allow this.  I suspect this wouldn't play well with the shareholders in the Home Counties, whose preferences seem to play a large part in Labour's policies.
Verdict: Probably not a candidate for the Labour manifesto

Free nursery places for children from 12 months
The most recent statement I can find on this was a speech by Johann Lamont in early October in which she ruled out making all childcare free, although she did announce plans to make it more affordable by capping the cost and offering free childcare for women who want to go to college to gain job-related skills.  Kezia Dugdale's name pops up again in relation to a visit to Finland to see their system of childcare, which apparently enthused her.  The policy could, of course, change depending on the outcome of the leadership election.
Verdict: Something around childcare likely to be included, but unlikely to be quite this radical.

It will be interesting to see what, if any, influence this has as we get closer to the General Election.

(The underlying data tables for the survey can be found here)

Tuesday, 18 November 2014

What's in a name?

Today's politicians are trained to work with the media, and draw on a range of standard techniques when being interviewed.  Andrew Marr outlines some of the techniques he uses in this article, where he also explains some of the techniques politicians use too.

One thing that they all do is address the interviewer by their first name, while interviewers generally address the politician themselves more formally, eg Mr Smith or Ms Brown.  At it's basic level, this emphasises the power differential between the two.  It's reminiscent of the school classroom, where pupils are addressed by their first name, while the teacher is addresses by their formal title.

Personally I find the use of the the interviewer's first name quite jarring, especially on the radio.  I also find that politicians tend to overdo it.  Yesterday's interview with Neil Findlay on Good Morning Scotland provides an example of this.

Mr Findlay appears to have attended the same school of interviewing as Johann Lamont.  Why is that that Labour politicians seem unable to think through what they're saying to its logical conclusion?  They come along with a sound-bite policy and are then shot down when the interviewer takes that policy to its logical conclusion.  For example, Neil Findlay had a sound-bite about how his policy as leader of Labour in Scotland would be to get rid of Trident.  However, when taken to its logical conclusion and asked how he would do this if the Labour leader in London decided to renew Trident, he floundered.  He clearly hadn't thought about it.  Similarly when asked about re-nationalising the railways, a simple question about the costs was all it took to derail (sorry) him.

We've seen this before, famously when Johann Lamont was asked to explain Labour in Scotland's policies on further tax powers for Scotland.  It begins to look as if Labour politicians in Scotland are simply parrots, repeating whatever phrase is flavour of the day and has been supplied to them.  Thinkers need not apply.

Monday, 17 November 2014

Back in your box

On the internet comment threads since the referendum there has been a distinct flavour anti-Scottishness.  The comments tend to come in a couple of flavours.

'The referendum result was No, you should just accept it'.  
This tends to come up any time having another referendum is mentioned, as if the last referendum was a one-off which could never be repeated.  The key phrase that comes in here is usually 'the settled will of the Scottish people'.  It's akin to saying 'the Tories won the last General Election so we should just accept the settled will of the British people.'  I can just see Labour supporters agreeing to that one.  There does seem to be a fear of another referendum, possibly because the result of the last one was not a resounding endorsement for the status quo, and so another would not be guaranteed to produce the result that Westminster wants, ie for Scotland to remain in the union.
 
'We can't allow the Scottish tail to wag the Westminster dog'
This one comes up in any discussion of greater powers for the Scottish parliament or of the SNP possibly holding the balance of power if there is no clear winner of the next General Election, which seems quite likely.  There is also a related strain of comments along the lines of 'we can't allow Scots politicians to hold any positions of power at Westminster'.  The thinking behind this one seems to be that Westminster knows best and it's not for Scots to question their decisions.

I asked on one of the comment threads just what was so terrifying about Scottish independence and got this answer:

The fact that it could become a reality on just some pathetic 51% (45% of the electorate) vote? And that it could then oblige EWANI to pay heavily to take back the failed state on its northern land border about 20 years down the line?
I also see nothing wrong with abolishing the Scottish Parliament, should the UK Gov determine that it is being misused etc.
 Hmmm, apparently a 51% result for independence would be pathetic, but a 55% result for staying in the union is a ringing endorsement?  I also love the assumption that rUK would inevitably prosper while Scotland would inevitably fail.  As for that last sentence, I think it encapsulates the typical view of the unionists that Westminster is in charge and no challenge to that is to be tolerated.  And that, I think, gets to the nub of the matter.

I haven't named the particular poster who made that response, as it wouldn't be fair to pick on that person.  However, their response is quite typical of what you can see on comment threads relating to Scottish independence, and is actually quite mild.  Some responses are considerably more vitriolic.

Scottish independence seems to create deep fear amongst the political classes, as they will never willingly give up any part of their power.  We have unsettled them with the last referendum.  Let's keep them on the back foot.

Sunday, 16 November 2014

Balance of power

The SNP conference is over, the old leader stepped down and the new leader in place.  From the livestream, we saw a picture of a buoyant, energised party, full of confidence and ready to do whatever it takes to gain Scotland's independence.

Nicola Sturgeon gave her first speech as leader, in which she stated that the SNP would never enter a coalition with the Tories and set out some conditions for supporting a Labour government, such as granting new powers to Holyrood, a rethink on austerity and not placing a new generation of nuclear weapons on the Clyde.

Now here comes the bucket of cold water. There are a number of flaws in this rosy scenario.

One of the SNP's stated aims is to electorally obliterate the Labour party in Scotland in May.  The polls are currently suggesting that this is feasible.  However, the logical extension of this would be why would Labour in London agree to some sort of loose arrangement for support of a minority government with the SNP, if the SNP were the cause of Labour having very few seats in Scotland?  It wouldn't play well with their supporters.

Another factor in play is that the polls at UK level put the SNP and LibDems on very similar percentages.  If these translated into seats, it may well be the LibDems who are being courted again, not the SNP.

I've been participating in a number of online comment threads about the SNP conference over the last two days, and there is a distinct but detectable resentment of the Scots for (a) not shutting up about independence and for talking about another referendum and (b) possibly having power over the English by enabling Labour to push through unpopular legislation.

The first part is an interesting one, and I might explore that in another post, since it's kind of off-topic for this one.

The second part is easily disproved, as the SNP do not vote on England-only legislation out of principle.  This doesn't appear to be well-known south of the border and maybe the SNP should make more of this.  However, this would lead to something of a dilemma for a minority Labour government, as it wouldn't be able to pass legislation on things like health or education without garnering support from elsewhere, and if it can do that, why would it need the SNP?

As for not supporting a new generation of nuclear weapons on the Clyde, I suspect that Labour would be able to garner support from the Tories on that one, as they both appear to need to retain the 'punching above our weight' status thing.  And if that happened, they would also vote to keep them anywhere they pleased.  Since Trident is already on the Clyde, and both parties are keen on austerity, it's highly unlikely they'd spend the money to build another facility for the new ones.

As a member of the SNP, I like the idea of our party having some power at Westminster, of being able to 'hold their feet to the fire'.  However, if we're going to do this, we need to be realistic.  There's a real danger at the moment of the party members becoming complacent, when we really need to fight the next election as if we were bottom of the polls.




Saturday, 15 November 2014

Say hello, wave goodbye

Day 1 of the SNP conference, and the two major topics being reported are Alex Salmond's farewell speech as leader and whether Nicola Sturgeon will call for another referendum on independence.

Mr Salmond's speech was something of a barnstormer,   He reviewed his time as leader of the SNP, citing successes such as free education, the council tax freeze, the introduction of the living wage and the efforts to protect Scots from the bedroom tax.  He reviewed the referendum, and excoriated the Labour party and its role in it.  He praised Nicola Sturgeon and John Swinney, citing the latter as 'the only finance minister in Europe to balance the budget'.  He also gave a clear warning to Westminster that the issue of Scottish independence has not gone away, and that any attempt to renege on their promises made in the Vow would result in 'Scotland taking matters into its own hands'.  (Anyone else detect a hint of a potential UDI in that?)  At the end of the speech he received a seven minute standing ovation.

In her first speech as leader Nicola Sturgeon laid out her priorities as leader.  First and foremost she wants to see the promised powers delivered to Scotland.  To ensure this, the SNP needs a strong showing at the Westminster elections in May 2015, something which looks very likely according to the latest polls.  She also said the gaining independence for Scotland was one of the top three priorities for the SNP, but that Yes activists should not look for another referendum in the near future, and that independence could only be won by persuasion such that the next referendum would be successful in gaining a majority for independence.  However, she does see the scenario where England votes to leave the EU while Scotland does not as a possible trigger for another referendum.

Looking through some of the comment threads on this, it's quite amazing how hostile a substantial number of people are to the thought of another referendum and of Scottish independence.  One would have to wonder what it is they fear, given that those same people are generally the ones trotting out the 'subsidy junkie' jibes and loudly proclaiming how Scotland could never manage alone.

Both Mr Salmond and Ms Sturgeon declared that they are in favour of Yes activists standing under the SNP banner at the general election, which would suggest that a formal Yes Alliance is not on the cards.

Party conferences are very much about preaching to the converted, and both speakers were greeted with rapturous applause.  However, the overall impression from the party conference is one of a party in buoyant, confident mood, quite the opposite of what many of their opponents expected following the referendum defeat.  We definitely live in interesting times.


Friday, 14 November 2014

#ThanksAlex

I remember when I first became really aware of my nationality.  Back in antediluvian times I was about to sit my O grades, and we had to fill in a form.  We were made to sit in a lecture hall while the teachers walked us through the process of filling in the required information.  We came to 'Nationality'.  I was about to fill it in as 'Scottish', but was stopped by a teacher and informed that 'Scottish' was not a nationality, and that I must put 'British'.  I was puzzled.  I was born and lived in a country called Scotland, therefore my nationality was Scottish.  British made no sense to me.

Three years later there was the first referendum on Scottish Devolution. I was very new to the voting process at that point, but I read about the issues and voted Yes.  As history shows, the result of the referendum was a Yes, but due to last minute shenanigans it was disregarded after the implementation of the notorious 40% rule.  It was my introduction to the duplicity of politicians and was something of an eye opener.

In 1997 we got another referendum on whether we should have a Scottish parliament.  Again I voted Yes.  Again we won, but this time the result was accepted and the Holyrood parliament came into being.

Up till that point I had been a Labour voter, in the tradition of my family.  However, politics for me was something that went on in the background and I wasn't a member of any political party or really politically active.

I first really became aware of Alex Salmond as anything other than a name when I saw a party political broadcast from the SNP some time after this.  It consisted of Mr Salmond talking to a group of people.  I don't remember the content of what he was saying, but I remember being struck by how natural he was in talking to people, how he avoided the usual cliches heard from politicians of every stripe.  He impressed me far more than any of the other politicians of the time.

As Holyrood developed, I began to lean more towards the SNP and began to vote for them in all of the elections, local, Scottish and national.  Still, however, I wasn't quite ready to make the move into actual political activism.  The game-changer was, of course, the recent referendum on Independence.

I'd like to thank Alex Salmond for making the referendum possible.  It was unfortunate that Yes didn't win, but I suspect that, in terms of the grand plan, the majority in Holyrood was unexpectedly early.  Had the majority not been won until 2016, I suspect we would have won a subsequent referendum.

I'd also like to thank Alex Salmond for leaving a legacy of politically aware and, in many cases, active ordinary people.  No longer is politics seen in Scotland as an esoteric pastime only enjoyed by a few anoraks.  Instead thousands of people are getting out and trying to make a difference.  Even those who are not active are far more aware of politics and are less likely to simply follow the old traditions.

I hope we haven't seen the last of Mr Salmond.  He's not perfect by any manner of means, but he is head and shoulders above the current crop of party leaders.  Indeed, if rumours are true and he stands for Westminster again, he could be a thorn in the side of Westminster for sometime to come, standing up for the interests of Scotland.  Won't that be a sight to see.

#Thanks Alex