Pages

Friday, 7 November 2014

Dear Labour

Dear Labour

There's no easy way to say this, so we'll just come right out with it.  It's over, and it's time for us both to move on.

We started out with a lot of hope and determination to make things better for everyone, and for a long time it worked.  We improved the lot of many people, giving them things such as the NHS, unemployment benefits and a decent education.  We helped lots of our children to reach their full potential and lifted them out of poverty, both financial and of ambition.  We were good together.

Lately, though,  you've been spending a lot more time with your smart friends down south, and you've been more interested with ingratiating yourself with their children, many of whom have a much more individualistic view on life.  Now it's got to the point where our ideas have diverged too far for it to work any longer.  We nearly left you in September, but gave you one more chance to prove you still cared.

We've met someone else.  They're a little younger than you, but they want the same things that we still want.  They've also got other friends who share their ideals.  We're moving on.

Hope things work out for you with your new family.

Scotland

PS, Tell Ed we hope the extraction of the silverware from his back isn't too painful.

Thursday, 6 November 2014

Marches and bonfires

'Remember, remember the fifth of November, gunpowder, treason and plot...'

This was the reason why Anonymous chose this date for their Million Mask March, which took place in major cities throughout the world.  There were marches in Edinburgh and Glasgow, which seem to have passed off peacefully, although there does appear to have been some trouble at the London March. 

Anonymous are an interesting phenomenon.  There are no leaders and very few rules.  Their key characteristics are "(1) an unrelenting moral stance on issues and rights, regardless of direct provocation; (2) a physical presence that accompanies online hacking activity; and (3) a distinctive brand."  Members wear the now famous Guy Fawkes mask, which is probably why most people find them rather sinister.

I have some sympathy with the aims of Anonymous, but I wouldn't wear the mask.  I'm not ashamed or afraid of being a Scottish nationalist and see no reason to hide that I am.

In other Guy Fawkes Night news, the Waterloo Bonfire Society decided that the guy to be placed on top of their bonfire this year would be Alex Salmond.   This came to light when a member of staff at the local council tweeted a picture of one of the effigies passing their offices.  Complaints were made, leading to the withdrawal of the two effigies and an investigation by the police into a racially-motivated hate crime.

I think that last was really an overreaction, giving a bit of silliness far more attention than it deserved.  Certainly Alex Salmond himself took it in good part.  However, the reaction from the Society itself and its supporters appears to have been 'It's just a joke'.  Ah, the clarion cry of bullies everywhere when called out. 

Anyway at least we now know - clearly Nessie is a 'Yessie' ;)

Wednesday, 5 November 2014

Leaders and referendums

It would appear that Jim Murphy is the leading candidate for the new leader of Labour in Scotland, at least as far as the MP/MSP/MEP block is concerned in the collegiate system favoured by the Scottish branch, having gained the support of 43 of the members of this voting block.  Kezia Dugdale is the favoured candidate for deputy, with an even bigger number of endorsements.

Labour in Scotland uses the electoral college system of voting for the leader and deputy.  In this case there are three voting blocks: the MPs/MSPs and MEPs, the trades unions and the rank and file members of the party.  However, not all voting blocks are equal, with the vote of one of the various MPs counting for more than a vote from the trades unions or the rank and file members.  There is an explanation here of how it works, albeit it's from the previous leadership election for the UK party.
The procedures have been reviewed and are due to change, but have not yet done so.

If Mr Murphy wins, then there is the question of whether he contests his current seat as an MP in 2015 or stands down and waits until 2016 to stand as an MSP.  Current thinking seems to be that he would stand down as an MP and stand for election as an MSP in 2016.  Given the current state of the polls for 2016 this could be quite risky, given Labour's current low standing, and may result in Mr Murphy's ambition to be First Minister falling at the first hurdle.  However, there is a long time between now and 2016, so things could change quite a lot.

Meantime in Wales, their First Minister, Carwyn Jones, has expressed support for Nicola Sturgeon's policy of adding an amendment to any legislation for an EU in/out referendum to state that a majority must return a vote to leave in each of the four home nations before a BREXIT could be triggered.  This was dismissed by David Cameron previously, when he stated at Prime Minister's Questions that the result should be predicated on a simple majority.  It will be interesting to see any comments from Northern Irish politicians on the subject. 

If the result of the EU in/out referendum was to leave, but with only England having a majority in favour, this could well trigger another referendum on Scottish Independence.  In that case, I think the Unionists could well have a real fight on their hands to retain Scotland in the UK.  Indeed, the effect could well be for England to leave the UK, leaving the celtic nations in the remaining union.  Interesting times indeed!


Tuesday, 4 November 2014

A Game of (Labour) Thrones

I see Jim Murphy has resigned from the shadow cabinet in order to pursue his new career as leader of Labour in Scotland.  He strikes me as being the Roose Bolton of this particular version of Game of Thrones, ruthlessly disposing of rivals on order to become King in the North. The equivalent of the Red Wedding would be the removal of Johann Lamont and Anas Sarwar which allegedly came about as a result of internal feuds.  It's widely rumoured that Margaret Currant, the Cersei Lannister of this particular version of Game of Thrones, will be moved into the vacancy created by Mr Murphy's resignation, something that would be regarded as a demotion for her, just as it was for Mr Murphy.  In the book Cersei spends her time plotting but isn't very good at it and is ultimately side-lined.

The nominations for deputy leader closed yesterday, with only two candidates having come forward: Kezia Dugdale and Katy Clark.  This leaves Sarah Boyack looking unlikely to win the leadership, as she now doesn't have a running mate.  A bit like Lysa Arryn, who spends most of Game of Thrones isolated and without much influence on events.  Let's hope she doesn't come to a political sticky end.

Meanwhile Labour continues its slow collapse, with Alastair Darling and Anne McGuire both announcing that they will stand down at the General Election in May.  Looks like Labour need to remember the Stark motto - Winter is Coming.

Monday, 3 November 2014

Rats and stables

The big news story of yesterday is the Alastair Darling is to stand down as MP for Edinburgh South at the General Election in May, the reason being given as that he wants to retire while he's still relatively young.  I have seen some comments that this might give Jim Murphy the opportunity he's looking for to become an MSP, if an MSP for the region were to stand down as an MSP to stand as an MP instead, thus leaving a vacancy for Mr Murphy to fill.  I don't think this is a likely scenario however, as most of the MSP seats in the Edinburgh area are held by SNP, with only one being held by Labour (Malcolm Chisholm in Edinburgh North and Leith) by a very slender margin.  Since there would be no safe seats for Labour in the area, and the MSP standing down would lose their resettlement allowance by leaving their post early, I can't see this happening.

 Mr Darling has also indicated that he would like to campaign for the UK to remain in the EU, describing it as 'boil that need to be lanced'.  There now seems to be a certain inevitability about an EU in/out referendum, which is even recognised in Europe, with Angela Merkel saying that Germany would accept an UK exit rather than compromise on the rules on free movement of labour.  This last ought to be a warning to David Cameron that Europe's patience is beginning to wear thin.  Credit to Mr Darling, however, for consistency.  He campaigned to retain the UK union and now he intends to campaign to retain the UK's part in the European Union.

There was also a story in the Telegraph yesterday about how MPs who have been accused of abusing the expenses system will escape official investigation after a large amount of paperwork on the matter was shredded.  Looks like the Augean stables remain as filthy as ever then.


Sunday, 2 November 2014

May the best man win


 This week we have seen the press in full flow, talking up Jim Murphy as the next leader of Labour in Scotland.  In fact, in reading the papers or watching TV news you would be hard put to learn that there are two other candidates for the position, since there has been little or no coverage of their views. This may be partly because Mr Murphy has the advantage of being someone the media has actually heard of, given his profile as a Westminster MP and member of the shadow cabinet.

The only other candidate who has been given anything other than a name-check is Neil Findlay, who is being backed by Unison.  Sadly Sarah Boyack has garnered very little interest from anywhere.

 Mr Murphy launched his campaign in Edinburgh, and offered an apology to the Scottish people for not listening to their views, given that the Scottish electorate had not voted for a Labour majority in 2007 and 2011.  He stated that Labour in Scotland needs to change to take account of this.  Almost immediately after this speech, Unison made their announcement that they would not be supporting him, and Unite said that Mr Murphy would have to do an awful lot more to convince them.  Not the flying start he was hoping for then.

The press are making much of Mr Murphy's part in the Better Together-No Thanks campaign in the recent referendum, although the following quote from the Guardian is fairly typical of the mainstream media:
 We saw that during the referendum when he was the street-fighting star of the no campaign with his gutsy “100 Towns in 100 Days” tour of public squares where he used an Irn-Bru crate as his soapbox and made himself a martyr to Nationalist egg-throwers.
 No exaggeration or inaccuracy there.

Mr Murphy's campaign sees the return of some members of the Better Together campaign, with Blair McDougall and Rob Shorthouse both being involved in an advisory capacity and, according to the Sunday Herald, Alastair Darling and several other members also being involved.  He also has the support of John McTernan, which may prove to be something of a double-edged sword.

So far two people have announced their candidacy for the deputy leadership position: Katy Clark MP and Kezia Dugdale MSP.  It would appear that Ms Clark will campaign on a joint ticket with Mr Findlay and Ms Dugdale will campaign along with Mr Murphy.  Many of the unions seem to be supporting the Findlay/Clark ticket on the basis that they will provide an alternative to the market-driven policies currently espoused by Labour.  Given that the unions account for one-third of the votes in the electoral college method used by Labour in Scotland for internal party elections, this is not good news for the Murphy camp.

I think I need to send out for more popcorn - this one looks like it may have more twists than a downhill slalom.



Saturday, 1 November 2014

Good news week

It's been a week of good news for the SNP.

First there was the news of the Ipsos Mori poll conducted by STV, which predicted a near-total wipeout for Labour in the general election in May.  Using the site Electoral Calculus and entering the figures from their poll, this shows only 4 Labour seats and 1 LibDem seat would be returned, with the rest being SNP.  According to their website this would have the following implications:

Those who would lose their seat include Jim Murphy, who is standing to be the next leader of Scottish Labour, Douglas Alexander and Margaret Curran, according to seat predictor electoralcalculus.co.uk. The site assumes uniform swings across constituencies.
The only Scottish Labour MPs who would survive would be Willie Bain in Glasgow North East, Tom Clarke in Coatbridge, Chryston and Bellshill, Gordon Brown in Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath and Ian Davidson in Glasgow South West.
The Liberal Democrats would lose all but one of their seats, with only Scottish secretary Alistair Carmichael surviving and high-profile victims including Danny Alexander and Charles Kennedy.
The general trend is backed up by another poll from YouGov which  while not quite as dramatic as the Ipsos Mori poll, does still indicate a melt-down for Labour support..

The second bit of good news was from the by-election in North Coast and Cumbraes on Thursday, when the SNP's Grace McLean was elected as councillor, replacing Alex McLean, following his death. The results were:

Drew Cochrane - Independent
1190       
Toni Dawson – Scottish Conservative and Unionist
1125
Meilan Henderson – UK Independence Party (UKIP)
192
Grace McLean – Scottish National Party (SNP)
2021
Valerie Reid – Scottish Labour Party
691



In itself, the result merely showed the previous SNP councillor being replaced by another SNP councillor.  However, the showing for Labour, in a Labour held consituency at parliamentary level, is quite telling, and at council level is lower than in the previous council elections.


Lastly we had another result from the Ipsos Mori poll for STV showing 66% of Scots would support another independence referendum being held within the next 10 years, while 58% would support another referendum in the next 5 years.  Given that 45% of voters supported independence at the last referendum, this would tend to indicate that a fair proportion of No voters may be changing their minds on the subject.

The danger here for the SNP would be to allow a certain complacency to set in as a result of these stories.  It would be very tempting to see the fight for the General Election as being already won, and to sit back and coast.  This would be a mistake.  While there is nothing wrong with enjoying the good news for a couple of days, the hard work must begin again next week.  The SNP need to campaign as if they are well behind in the polls and must work hard to win the support of the Electorate.

Harold Wilson has often been attributed with the quote 'a week is a long time in politics'.  If that's the case, 6 months is an eternity in politics, and much could change between now and the General Election next May.  The SNP should take nothing for granted.