There he stood, the hero of the hour. Tasked by the leaders at Westminster in the final week of the referendum campaign with doing whatever it took to save the Union, Gordon Brown came up with the Vow. He staked his reputation on Westminster delivering extensive new powers to Scotland to a strict timetable of his devising. It was enough to persuade the undecided and the waverers. The ones who wanted more powers for Scotland but the security blanket of the Union. The ones who wanted the best of both worlds. The ones who wanted to believe that Labour still had Scotland's best interests at heart.
There he stands, his reputation in tatters. It took all of nine hours for David Cameron to renege on Mr Brown's promises by linking any new powers for Scotland to 'English votes for English laws (EV4EL)', something that was never mentioned in the Vow. The strict timetable is being treated more as a set of guidelines. Mr Brown has been reduced the hi-jacking someone else's petition calling on Westminster to keep its promises on more powers. The final humiliation must be that in the debate in the House of Commons yesterday on new powers for Scotland, none of the three leaders of the Government and Opposition bothered to turn up, and the debate itself was mainly about EV4EL and various other digressions. This the same Gordon Brown who was praised by the Unionists for his statesman-like qualities during the referendum campaign, but who now sees the trap into which he and his party have been led. The epithet applied to King James 6th &1st seems apt for him - 'the wisest fool in Christendom'.
I almost feel sorry for him. Almost.
Wednesday, 15 October 2014
Tuesday, 14 October 2014
The Independence Diet
Like many people in Scotland, I'm overweight. Like most overweight people, I'm trying to do something about it. It's not easy though.
Firstly, you need an incentive to go on a diet. Maybe you decided not to go and see a movie with your friends because the cinema is on the first floor and you couldn't manage the stairs. Maybe you saw the most gorgeous outfit, but you couldn't have it because they don't make it in a large enough size. Maybe you've developed some medical issues. Whatever it is, there will be a trigger.
So you tell your friends that you've decided to lose the weight. Some will be supportive, but some will tell you that you're fine, that a little extra weight suits you, so why bother? Nevertheless, you're determined that this is it, you're going to be that skinny person.
Maybe you go along to a diet club, where they tell you how to manage your calories. Maybe you go to a gym, where they give you a weight reduction exercise programme. In both cases they lie to you. The diet club tells you that you can eat what you want, never have to be hungry and still lose weight as long as you stick to their programme. The gym tells you you will lose weight without sore muscles or having to spend loads of time in the gym.
Eventually you run out of steam. The diet is too restrictive or the gym takes up too much of your time. Your friends persuade you that a chocolate biscuit or a cake or a curry won't do you any harm, and you succumb, thinking that you can always go back on the diet on Monday. Your own brain subverts your efforts, because brains like to stick with what they know.
To lose weight successfully, you have to accept that you will be hungry at times, or that you will have to spend more time than you'd like at the gym. You also have to accept that it's not a time-limited thing, that's it's a permanent lifestyle change.
What has this to do with independence? The parallels are quite striking.
First of all, we need an incentive. This time around there really wasn't a strong incentive for most people, the ones who haven't really thought about independence or who don't see anything wrong with the status quo. The next referendum therefore really needs some strong reason to trigger it. Maybe a Tory-UKIP coalition wreaking havoc with their policies, or England voting to leave Europe while Scotland votes to stay in. Something on which people will have strong opinions.
Next we need to be realistic. This time around the No campaign painted the blackest picture possible, while the Yes campaign erred a bit too much on the sunny side. We need to tell people that in the short term after they vote for independence, there will possibly be pain. There will be negotiations to be had, and they won't all go our way. We will need to develop relationships with other countries, not all of which will be supportive. We need to reassure people that short-term pain will be long-term gain.
Finally we need to show them the picture of Scotland at the end of the process. It needs to be a realistic picture though. A Scotland which is a successful, prosperous nation, but not one that is without problems. To show otherwise would be like me thinking I can look like a supermodel once I reach my target weight. Lovely dream, but it's not going to happen!
Firstly, you need an incentive to go on a diet. Maybe you decided not to go and see a movie with your friends because the cinema is on the first floor and you couldn't manage the stairs. Maybe you saw the most gorgeous outfit, but you couldn't have it because they don't make it in a large enough size. Maybe you've developed some medical issues. Whatever it is, there will be a trigger.
So you tell your friends that you've decided to lose the weight. Some will be supportive, but some will tell you that you're fine, that a little extra weight suits you, so why bother? Nevertheless, you're determined that this is it, you're going to be that skinny person.
Maybe you go along to a diet club, where they tell you how to manage your calories. Maybe you go to a gym, where they give you a weight reduction exercise programme. In both cases they lie to you. The diet club tells you that you can eat what you want, never have to be hungry and still lose weight as long as you stick to their programme. The gym tells you you will lose weight without sore muscles or having to spend loads of time in the gym.
Eventually you run out of steam. The diet is too restrictive or the gym takes up too much of your time. Your friends persuade you that a chocolate biscuit or a cake or a curry won't do you any harm, and you succumb, thinking that you can always go back on the diet on Monday. Your own brain subverts your efforts, because brains like to stick with what they know.
To lose weight successfully, you have to accept that you will be hungry at times, or that you will have to spend more time than you'd like at the gym. You also have to accept that it's not a time-limited thing, that's it's a permanent lifestyle change.
What has this to do with independence? The parallels are quite striking.
First of all, we need an incentive. This time around there really wasn't a strong incentive for most people, the ones who haven't really thought about independence or who don't see anything wrong with the status quo. The next referendum therefore really needs some strong reason to trigger it. Maybe a Tory-UKIP coalition wreaking havoc with their policies, or England voting to leave Europe while Scotland votes to stay in. Something on which people will have strong opinions.
Next we need to be realistic. This time around the No campaign painted the blackest picture possible, while the Yes campaign erred a bit too much on the sunny side. We need to tell people that in the short term after they vote for independence, there will possibly be pain. There will be negotiations to be had, and they won't all go our way. We will need to develop relationships with other countries, not all of which will be supportive. We need to reassure people that short-term pain will be long-term gain.
Finally we need to show them the picture of Scotland at the end of the process. It needs to be a realistic picture though. A Scotland which is a successful, prosperous nation, but not one that is without problems. To show otherwise would be like me thinking I can look like a supermodel once I reach my target weight. Lovely dream, but it's not going to happen!
Monday, 13 October 2014
Smith Commission Submissions (Part 3)
Today I have been reading the last of the party submissions to the Smith Commission, that of the SNP. Declaration of interest here - I am a member of the SNP.
The basic principle of the SNP submission is that all powers that are not explicitly reserved to Westminster should fall under the control of the Scottish Parliament, and that the onus should be on Westminster to prove their case for retaining whatever powers they wish. This is the opposite approach to the other parties, who are considering devolution from the point of view of granting more powers to the Scottish parliament and retaining those which have not been explicitly devolved.
Most of the arguments presented were well-rehearsed during the referendum campaign, so there are few surprises in their submission. There is discussion of the Vow (complete with quotes from the leaders of the Unionist parties) and what the SNP take this to mean. They also present the results of a survey showing the level of support by the Scottish people of various further powers.
There is a clear strand throughout the document of Scotland becoming much more of a partner to Westminster rather than a subsidiary by, for example, obliging Westminster to take account of the views and positive suggestion of the Scottish parliament with regard to reserved matters. There is also a clear intention to give Scotland more of an identity within the community of nations, by allowing Scotland to have its own voice on matters within its own devolved competence. This, I assume, is a first step towards eventual independence, by normalising Scotland as having a voice independent of Westminster, thus making eventual independence a much less drastic-seeming step.
In all the SNP's proposals are wide-ranging and in this regard very similar to the Scottish Greens and more extensive than those of Scottish Labour and the Scottish Conservatives. I somehow doubt that the other parties will agree to all of the SNP's proposals, since they take Scotland far closer to independence than the others would be prepared to countenance.
It will be interesting to see the outcome of the Smith Commission. I think the SNP will be disappointed, but I also think the other parties may well be obliged to concede rather more than they propose to. I shall watch this particular space with interest!
The basic principle of the SNP submission is that all powers that are not explicitly reserved to Westminster should fall under the control of the Scottish Parliament, and that the onus should be on Westminster to prove their case for retaining whatever powers they wish. This is the opposite approach to the other parties, who are considering devolution from the point of view of granting more powers to the Scottish parliament and retaining those which have not been explicitly devolved.
Most of the arguments presented were well-rehearsed during the referendum campaign, so there are few surprises in their submission. There is discussion of the Vow (complete with quotes from the leaders of the Unionist parties) and what the SNP take this to mean. They also present the results of a survey showing the level of support by the Scottish people of various further powers.
There is a clear strand throughout the document of Scotland becoming much more of a partner to Westminster rather than a subsidiary by, for example, obliging Westminster to take account of the views and positive suggestion of the Scottish parliament with regard to reserved matters. There is also a clear intention to give Scotland more of an identity within the community of nations, by allowing Scotland to have its own voice on matters within its own devolved competence. This, I assume, is a first step towards eventual independence, by normalising Scotland as having a voice independent of Westminster, thus making eventual independence a much less drastic-seeming step.
In all the SNP's proposals are wide-ranging and in this regard very similar to the Scottish Greens and more extensive than those of Scottish Labour and the Scottish Conservatives. I somehow doubt that the other parties will agree to all of the SNP's proposals, since they take Scotland far closer to independence than the others would be prepared to countenance.
It will be interesting to see the outcome of the Smith Commission. I think the SNP will be disappointed, but I also think the other parties may well be obliged to concede rather more than they propose to. I shall watch this particular space with interest!
Sunday, 12 October 2014
Hope Over Fear, George Square, 12/10/2014
Some pictures from the Hope Over Fear rally today
Gives you some idea of the attendance. There were some excellent speakers and bands. Everyone seemed to be having a good time, lots of smiles and hugs :)
Gives you some idea of the attendance. There were some excellent speakers and bands. Everyone seemed to be having a good time, lots of smiles and hugs :)
Smith Commission Submissions (Part 2)
Today I have read the submissions from the Scottish Labour party and the Scottish Liberal Democrats.
The first thing that springs to mind when reading the Scottish Labour submission is 'buzzword bingo'. 'Pooling and sharing' features heavily, and we get the usual soundbites such as 'hardworking people'. Their contention is that social union is incompatible with independence. Oh, and it only took until page 7 for them to to put the boot into the SNP, so they've beaten the Conservatives on that score.
I liked this quote:
Most of the paper consists of a discussion on tax powers and devolving power to local authorities. There was a paragraph Housing Benefit that kind of gives the game away though (my italics):
To sum up. Scottish Labour suggests that most powers remain with Westminster, with some tinkering around the edges of devolving some powers. And in their paper, they excoriate the SNP for their centralising tendencies. There's a bible quote about this - 'And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?'
And so to the Scottish Liberal Democrat submission. On the surface they are pitching for home rule. Most people would equate this with Devo Max (ie all powers at Holyrood, with the exception of defence and foreign affairs). However, this is not what they are proposing. Points, though, for widening the debate to include 'home rule' for the other home nations too.
They discuss at some length how they have been working for a federal Britain for 100 years. Their progress towards that goal so far would make an arthritic snail look speedy, so obviously they're not in a rush to get this done.
They do overtake the others in one respect though - SNP bashing begins on page 6.
I was slightly bemused by this paragraph:
To be fair to the LibDems, their fiscal proposals are more radical than those of Labour, but stop short of allowing oil revenues to be retained in Scotland. Clearly this would be a step too far. However, they do propose setting up an oil fund at UK level, which is some progress at least. The caveat being 'when conditions permit', which are some nice little weasel words slipped in to allow a get-out clause.
I would disagree with this paragraph:
Again, the LibDems' proposal suggests devolvement of more power to local authorities. In itself, this isn't a bad idea and is worth considering. However, I do wonder about the fact that the three major parties are all hugely in favour of this. Could it be something to do with the fact that they are more likely to have control at council level than at Holyrood level? Time will tell.
Their division of powers into three tiers, namely reserved, devolved and partnership seems quite complicated and would likely keep lawyers in the style they have become accustomed to.
(I'm slowly losing the will to live at this point - can you tell?).
There is a proposal for the institution of 'burgh councils', which would seem to be yet another tier of local councils below the larger district councils, these to be established where there is demand from local communities and to be funded by either by a share of the council tax or of local business rates. Yet elsewhere in the paper the LibDems tell us they are not in favour of fragmentation into smaller units at the UK level. A bit of a dichotomy there I think.
All in all, the Scottish LibDems have put together a comprehensive paper which does contain some good ideas. How many people will actually read it all the way through, however, is a different question.
The first thing that springs to mind when reading the Scottish Labour submission is 'buzzword bingo'. 'Pooling and sharing' features heavily, and we get the usual soundbites such as 'hardworking people'. Their contention is that social union is incompatible with independence. Oh, and it only took until page 7 for them to to put the boot into the SNP, so they've beaten the Conservatives on that score.
I liked this quote:
Without economic and political union, a genuine social union is all but impossible. Far more likely is a race to the bottom on tax and workers’ rights, ultimately leading to the erosion of welfare and pensions. The sharing union underpinned by political union, economic and social union – is the ultimate safeguard and guarantor of the Welfare State.Hmmm, have they reviewed their own party's record on this when last in office? And have they noticed what has happened under the Con-Dem government? Best use of irony I've seen so far.
Most of the paper consists of a discussion on tax powers and devolving power to local authorities. There was a paragraph Housing Benefit that kind of gives the game away though (my italics):
We are in favour of devolving Housing Benefit. This is the largest single benefit paid in Scotland after the state pension – amounting to £1.7 billion a year. We will use this power to abolish the Bedroom Tax, ensure secure funding for the provision of social housing and reduce abuse by unscrupulous private landlords.So apparently Scottish Labour expect to be in power after the next Holyrood General Election. Glad we sorted that one out.
To sum up. Scottish Labour suggests that most powers remain with Westminster, with some tinkering around the edges of devolving some powers. And in their paper, they excoriate the SNP for their centralising tendencies. There's a bible quote about this - 'And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?'
And so to the Scottish Liberal Democrat submission. On the surface they are pitching for home rule. Most people would equate this with Devo Max (ie all powers at Holyrood, with the exception of defence and foreign affairs). However, this is not what they are proposing. Points, though, for widening the debate to include 'home rule' for the other home nations too.
They discuss at some length how they have been working for a federal Britain for 100 years. Their progress towards that goal so far would make an arthritic snail look speedy, so obviously they're not in a rush to get this done.
They do overtake the others in one respect though - SNP bashing begins on page 6.
I was slightly bemused by this paragraph:
A useful contemporary illustration of the benefits of a United Kingdom which is of particular interest to me can be found in the remarkable success of Team GB in the London Olympics and Paralympics. The unity of support from the whole of the UK underpinned these successes and was the focus of the celebrations which followed themI don't remember celebrations following the Olympics - maybe I was asleep or something?
To be fair to the LibDems, their fiscal proposals are more radical than those of Labour, but stop short of allowing oil revenues to be retained in Scotland. Clearly this would be a step too far. However, they do propose setting up an oil fund at UK level, which is some progress at least. The caveat being 'when conditions permit', which are some nice little weasel words slipped in to allow a get-out clause.
I would disagree with this paragraph:
As internationalists we believe that, as part of the UK, Scotland benefits from a prominent role on the world stage: represented at a permanent seat on the UN Security Council; part of one of the leading members of the European Union, G8 and NATO; reserved positions on the International Monetary Fund and World Bank. Through the UK, Scotland is able to have meaningful impact on issues as diverse as climate change, the fight for international justice, the operation of the global trading system and arms control. Scotland’s voice is louder through the UK than it would be alone: we have the weight to argue our case and fight for a fair deal for ourselves and others. Even in non-political international organisations, such as those concerned with sport, science or culture, the combined weight of the United Kingdom will always be greater than the sum of its partsFrankly, under this arrangement, Scotland has no voice at all, as has been seen, for example, with a meeting on GM crops at EU level, where Scotland's views were famously overlooked because the representative in question had brought the wrong notes with him.
Again, the LibDems' proposal suggests devolvement of more power to local authorities. In itself, this isn't a bad idea and is worth considering. However, I do wonder about the fact that the three major parties are all hugely in favour of this. Could it be something to do with the fact that they are more likely to have control at council level than at Holyrood level? Time will tell.
Their division of powers into three tiers, namely reserved, devolved and partnership seems quite complicated and would likely keep lawyers in the style they have become accustomed to.
(I'm slowly losing the will to live at this point - can you tell?).
There is a proposal for the institution of 'burgh councils', which would seem to be yet another tier of local councils below the larger district councils, these to be established where there is demand from local communities and to be funded by either by a share of the council tax or of local business rates. Yet elsewhere in the paper the LibDems tell us they are not in favour of fragmentation into smaller units at the UK level. A bit of a dichotomy there I think.
All in all, the Scottish LibDems have put together a comprehensive paper which does contain some good ideas. How many people will actually read it all the way through, however, is a different question.
Saturday, 11 October 2014
Smith Commission Submissions (Part 1)
All the major Scottish parties submitted their proposals to the Smith Commission by the deadline of Friday 10th October. They are all available for viewing on the Smith Commission website.
I have made a start on reading the documents. There's only so much political documentation I can read at a sitting, so today I have read the proposals from the Scottish Conservatives and the Scottish Green Party (I'm going by the party names on the website - there's another discussion to be had about whether there is, in fact, a Scottish Conservative party. Maybe another post.)
The Scottish Conservative party's proposals are based on those of the Strathclyde Commission and are striking in that the only two areas they appear to consider are money and influence. There are extensive discussions on taxes and National Insurance, mainly justifying why the UK should retain overall control of the money while tinkering at the edges of allowing the Scottish Government to make policy decisions. One of the most amusing parts is where they declare that National Insurance should be retained at the UK level because it would be too difficult for companies to have to deal with two different agencies in collecting this tax. That's the multi-nationals that operate in numerous countries telt then - obviously having to deal with one more country's tax authorities would just be the final straw.
There are also extensive discussions on how the Scottish parliament should be run, including plans to ensure that all committees have an Opposition MSP as chairman, and how senior Civil Servants based in Scotland should be forced to serve part of the career in one or more UK Departments of State. Presumably so they can drink the Unionist kool-aid? Who knows. They are also very keen on devolving powers away from the Scottish Parliament to local authorities and individuals (I'm assuming they mean elected mayors and police commissioners by this).
The most amusing part comes on page 11, where, after doing so well, they put the boot into Alex Salmond and the SNP specifically. It kind of gives the game away, that their proposals are really to try and hamstring the SNP, their bitterest enemies it would appear.
Striking by their absence is any mention of energy policy, transport, media, equality and human rights, land reform and immigration. All these and more can be found in the submission of the Scottish Green party. Their proposals are wide-ranging and would see far more extensive powers granted to the Scottish Parliament, including the ability to have a voice in international affairs on behalf of Scotland where appropriate. They also make mention of TTIP, something conspicious by its absence from the Conservative party's proposals - clearly an oversight and I'm sure something they will be happy to share their views on if asked.
I am impressed by the Green's paper, and would be happy to see more of them in the Scottish Parliament. Certainly the picture they paint is a very appealing one.
That's all for today. Tomorrow I will read the proposals from Scottish Labour and the Scottish Liberal Democrats.
I have made a start on reading the documents. There's only so much political documentation I can read at a sitting, so today I have read the proposals from the Scottish Conservatives and the Scottish Green Party (I'm going by the party names on the website - there's another discussion to be had about whether there is, in fact, a Scottish Conservative party. Maybe another post.)
The Scottish Conservative party's proposals are based on those of the Strathclyde Commission and are striking in that the only two areas they appear to consider are money and influence. There are extensive discussions on taxes and National Insurance, mainly justifying why the UK should retain overall control of the money while tinkering at the edges of allowing the Scottish Government to make policy decisions. One of the most amusing parts is where they declare that National Insurance should be retained at the UK level because it would be too difficult for companies to have to deal with two different agencies in collecting this tax. That's the multi-nationals that operate in numerous countries telt then - obviously having to deal with one more country's tax authorities would just be the final straw.
There are also extensive discussions on how the Scottish parliament should be run, including plans to ensure that all committees have an Opposition MSP as chairman, and how senior Civil Servants based in Scotland should be forced to serve part of the career in one or more UK Departments of State. Presumably so they can drink the Unionist kool-aid? Who knows. They are also very keen on devolving powers away from the Scottish Parliament to local authorities and individuals (I'm assuming they mean elected mayors and police commissioners by this).
The most amusing part comes on page 11, where, after doing so well, they put the boot into Alex Salmond and the SNP specifically. It kind of gives the game away, that their proposals are really to try and hamstring the SNP, their bitterest enemies it would appear.
Striking by their absence is any mention of energy policy, transport, media, equality and human rights, land reform and immigration. All these and more can be found in the submission of the Scottish Green party. Their proposals are wide-ranging and would see far more extensive powers granted to the Scottish Parliament, including the ability to have a voice in international affairs on behalf of Scotland where appropriate. They also make mention of TTIP, something conspicious by its absence from the Conservative party's proposals - clearly an oversight and I'm sure something they will be happy to share their views on if asked.
I am impressed by the Green's paper, and would be happy to see more of them in the Scottish Parliament. Certainly the picture they paint is a very appealing one.
That's all for today. Tomorrow I will read the proposals from Scottish Labour and the Scottish Liberal Democrats.
Friday, 10 October 2014
Weekend events
There are a couple of events on this weekend that we will be attending.
On Saturday there is a Power of the People Rally in Livingston Square, Livingston (opposite Debenhams). There will be live music, speakers and a Christmas present collection for charity. All profits are also going to charity. Things will be kicking off at 1pm
On Sunday there is the Hope Over Fear Rally in George Square, Glasgow from 12 noon - 5pm. Again, there will be lots of speakers and live music, and it's intended that it should be a fun family event.
Hope to see you there!
On Saturday there is a Power of the People Rally in Livingston Square, Livingston (opposite Debenhams). There will be live music, speakers and a Christmas present collection for charity. All profits are also going to charity. Things will be kicking off at 1pm
On Sunday there is the Hope Over Fear Rally in George Square, Glasgow from 12 noon - 5pm. Again, there will be lots of speakers and live music, and it's intended that it should be a fun family event.
Hope to see you there!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)